What Did The Packers Give Up For Parsons
Alright, let’s talk about one of the most questionable trades in Green Bay Packers history—the one that sent Randall Cobb to Seattle in exchange for Darren McFadden and a first-round pick in 2014. Yeah, yeah, we know—it’s the kind of trade that makes Packers fans groan like a room full of old men at a bad football movie. But let’s break it down, because sometimes the weirdest moves teach us the most.
So, what did the Packers actually give up? Well, first, they sent Randall Cobb, the guy who could make a defender look like a toddler in a dance-off. He was fast, he was flashy, and he made every play look like a highlight reel. But here’s the kicker: the Packers were desperate for a running game, and Cobb wasn’t exactly a ground-and-pound type. (Sorry, Randy, but even you couldn’t carry the team like a true workhorse.)
The trade also included a first-round pick—the kind of pick that could’ve been a franchise-changer if you picked right. But let’s be real: the Packers’ draft luck that year was about as reliable as a Packers fan’s optimism during a 4-12 season. That pick turned into D.J. Moore, who was solid but not exactly a generational talent. Oof.
Must Read
What Did They Get Back?
In exchange, the Packers got Darren McFadden, a running back who was… let’s say unconventional. He was fast, sure, but he also had a habit of disappearing into the end zone like a ghost. The Packers were hoping he’d be their answer to a struggling offense, but let’s just say he didn’t exactly turn into Adrian Peterson.
And then there was a second-round pick—which, in hindsight, was probably the only real win in that whole mess. That pick became Jaire Alexander, who’s now a solid cornerback. So, at least one good thing came out of it, right? Well, yeah, but it’s like getting a free cookie when you ordered a pizza—nice, but not exactly what you were hoping for.
Why Did This Trade Happen?
Picture this: the Packers were in a rough spot. Aaron Rodgers was still the same genius he always was, but the offense was struggling, and the defense wasn’t exactly a powerhouse. The front office was looking for a way to shake things up, and they figured McFadden’s speed could be the key to breaking through. Spoiler alert: it wasn’t.
But here’s the thing—sometimes trades like this happen because teams are desperate. And let’s be honest, the Packers have been desperate more times than a fan at a Lambeau Field tailgate when the last hot dog is gone. They were trying to fix something that wasn’t broken, really, but just needed a little tweaking. Instead, they ended up with a running back who was more showboat than workhorse.

How Did It All Turn Out?
McFadden lasted three seasons in Green Bay before getting traded again—this time to the Carolina Panthers, where he finally found his groove. Meanwhile, the Packers kept drafting and developing their own running backs, like Ty Montgomery and Aaron Jones, who are now the real deal. So in the end, the trade didn’t exactly work out, but it also didn’t ruin the Packers forever.
And let’s not forget—Rodgers was still throwing for 4,000+ yards, and the defense was getting better. The Packers didn’t need McFadden to win Super Bowls; they just needed to keep doing what they were doing. Sometimes, the best trades are the ones that don’t happen at all.
What’s the Lesson Here?
This trade is a great example of how desperation can cloud judgment. The Packers were trying to fix a problem that didn’t really exist, and in the process, they gave up a solid player for a gamble that didn’t pay off. But hey, that’s football—sometimes you win, sometimes you learn.
And look at it this way: if the Packers had kept Cobb, would they have ever found Aaron Jones? Probably not. Sometimes you have to let go of what you love to get what you need. It’s like breaking up with a bad boyfriend—it hurts at first, but you end up happier in the long run.

The Silver Lining
Here’s the thing: even the worst trades can teach us something. The Packers learned that speed isn’t everything, and that sometimes the best players come from within. They also learned that Rodgers and the defense were more than enough to carry them to success—even if they had to make some tough calls along the way.
And who knows? Maybe one day, this trade will be remembered as a funny footnote in Packers history, like the time they traded for a player who lasted one season and then got traded again. (Looking at you, Brett Favre’s post-career life.)
So next time you’re groaning about a trade, remember: the Packers have been through worse. They’ve traded for players who lasted one game, one season, and even one quarter. But they always bounce back—because that’s what Packers fans do.
And hey, at least we got D.J. Moore out of it. Not bad for a trade that could’ve gone so much worse.
Now go enjoy a Packers win—because we all know they’re coming.
